Subscribe to the magazine
 
 
A Yale law professor argues that we’re not doing enough to empower the minority voices in America—and change should start at the local level:

The ideas Gerken is known for first took shape, appropriately enough, as a disagreement. Several years ago, not long after she’d been hired as a young professor at Harvard, she sat in on a pair of lectures by Cass Sunstein, the influential law scholar who was then a professor at the University of Chicago. What she heard Sunstein say, in brief, was that societies in which dissenting voices are encouraged tend to be more prosperous than ones where they are not. Gerken sat in the back of the hall with a notepad and listened, writing furiously. “If you had looked back,” Gerken says, “you would have wondered, why is that junior professor sitting there scribbling like a crazy person? Is she transcribing this speech? But it was just the opposite.”
In fact, Gerken was writing down all the ways in which she thought Sunstein was wrong. What Sunstein didn’t seem to realize, she wrote, was that in order for minority groups to have real influence in politics—in order for them to make meaningful contributions to the way society works—they had to have more than the right to make their voices heard. They had to have the power to actually do things their way.

"How to Fix America from Below." — Leon Neyfakh, Boston
More by Neyfakh

A Yale law professor argues that we’re not doing enough to empower the minority voices in America—and change should start at the local level:

The ideas Gerken is known for first took shape, appropriately enough, as a disagreement. Several years ago, not long after she’d been hired as a young professor at Harvard, she sat in on a pair of lectures by Cass Sunstein, the influential law scholar who was then a professor at the University of Chicago. What she heard Sunstein say, in brief, was that societies in which dissenting voices are encouraged tend to be more prosperous than ones where they are not. Gerken sat in the back of the hall with a notepad and listened, writing furiously. “If you had looked back,” Gerken says, “you would have wondered, why is that junior professor sitting there scribbling like a crazy person? Is she transcribing this speech? But it was just the opposite.”

In fact, Gerken was writing down all the ways in which she thought Sunstein was wrong. What Sunstein didn’t seem to realize, she wrote, was that in order for minority groups to have real influence in politics—in order for them to make meaningful contributions to the way society works—they had to have more than the right to make their voices heard. They had to have the power to actually do things their way.

"How to Fix America from Below." — Leon Neyfakh, Boston

More by Neyfakh

Get the weekly Longreads email

blog comments powered by Disqus
69 notes
  1. wingtipsandloafers reblogged this from longreads and added:
    Agree…
  2. forestnocturne reblogged this from thedustatdawn
  3. thedustatdawn reblogged this from longreads
  4. lostballoon reblogged this from longreads
  5. beatifical reblogged this from longreads
  6. knownforms reblogged this from longreads and added:
    This is fucking fascinating: “We were moving from a world where African-Americans and women were excluded entirely from...
  7. derrinyet reblogged this from longreads
  8. rodi83 reblogged this from longreads
  9. two--percent-milf reblogged this from longreads
  10. fatmanatee reblogged this from longreads and added:
    Been meaning to put together another reading list, this one is on the top of the list though.